Throughout the nineteenth century, the United
States faced the problem of epidemic disease in
the new metropolises that sprung up through the country. With the advent
of the Industrial Revolution and the influx of immigrants from Europe,
these cities had to deal with the many problems associated with massive
groups of people living in small areas. In the immigrant and industrial
communities there was a critical lack of sanitary conditions and the will
needed to correct the problem. Thus diseases such as yellow fever, tuberculosis,
and cholera swept through and cast the long shadow of death over the nation.
Since these diseases predominantly affected the lower classes and minorities
a curious pattern of inaction and denial led to little being done to stop
the epidemics. In fact, in the earlier part of the century, it was widely
held that this was a moral problem rather than a social and medical one.
The last large scale epidemic of cholera occurred
in 1873, ironically just a few years after most of the major population
centers had taken steps to prevent the disease. Unfortunately, the new
industrial capitals of the south had to deal with a large population of
African Americans just released from their bondage, coming to the towns
to find work. The disease, having sprung up in Memphis and Nashville, began
a certain and deadly path southward along the railroads. It first appeared
in Huntsville and then moved on down to Birmingham and Montgomery.
This paper will focus on the epidemic in Birmingham Alabama and how it
almost destroyed the city in its infancy.
Cholera has its origins in the Far East and moved
over to North America on trading vessels. It is primarily a water borne
disease occurring in the summer months. It can also be spread though physical
contact with victims and contaminated objects. It is thought of as more
horrible in a way than its fellows yellow fever and malaria because its
kills its victims so quickly. A victim can go to bed appearing perfectly
healthy and never wake up. Symptoms of the disease include "diarrhea,
acute spasmodic vomiting, and painful cramps." The epidemic
of 1873 was more even more virulent than other manifestations and even
killed victims within twelve hours.
Medical science was just beginning to come to
grips with the problems of infectious disease. Pasteur was studying germs
at this point in time and science was about to make great leaps forward.
However, trial and error were still the best methods for devising cures
for these diseases, and prevention was the first and only way to keep these
epidemics in check. If the cholera was diagnosed quickly enough and great
care was given to the victim then there was a very good survivability rate.
Unfortunately there was no set treatment and doctors had to basically experiment
on their patients to find out what would work best. Often victims used
quack remedies such as the "Simmons Liver Regulator" which were
advertised in the Mobile and Montgomery Papers. These "cure-alls"
invariably failed and often even harmed the patients. Thus Birmingham was
faced with a disease that they could neither prevent nor readily cure at
the time when the city was least able to deal with it.
On January 26, 1871 a group of ambitious men captained
by a Colonel J.R. Powell met to found the city of Birmingham Alabama. They
had high hopes for the city knowing that the surrounding area held the
vital resources of coal, iron, and limestone; the three key ingredients
in making steel. Thus the Magic City was born, In later years it would
be known as one of the great industrial capitals of the world and would
even become the second most important U.S. target on the Nazi Germany bombing
lists. However, Birmingham would face a great trial in its early years,
a threat that would halve its population and kill one hundred and twenty-eight
of its citizens. This menace to Birmingham, this "hideous invader
of our hearthstones" was no other than the dread epidemic of cholera,
feared around the world for its contagiousness and its high mortality rate.
The first victim of the epidemic, Virgil or Mr.
Y as he is sometimes referred to, arrived in Birmingham around the beginning
of June 1873. He was a healthy, "able-bodied" man until his belongings
arrived on June ninth. Within three days, he had become ill and died twenty-four
hours after first showing symptoms. Even though cholera had appeared
in Tennessee and the northern part of Alabama, the doctors were reluctant
to put a name to Virgil's killer, as obvious as the symptoms were. No cases
had been reported in the central part of Alabama and his fecal matter and
vomit were merely tossed out onto a hill that sloped down to the stream
that served the community of Baconsides. Several doctors suspected cholera
at this point but no great call was raised and the Board of Health did
not act to suppress the disease.
Baconsides lay just north of Fourth avenue north
between Eleventh and Fourteenth Street. The stream that Virgil's contaminated
fluids were exposed to was fed by a small pond on the east side of town
on Twenty Fourth street as well as a spring on the south side. The stream
ran all the way through the middle of town and there was not a worse water
source in Birmingham to expose the disease. The stream served not only
Baconsides but was connected to two wells on nineteenth and twenty first
street. Most of the northern parts of the city used this water but apparently
the disease did not move upstream with sufficient vigor to infect the inhabitants
yet.
Since the city of Birmingham was only two years
old, there had been little effort made to establish a clean water supply
for the whole community. The Birmingham Water Works had been established
by Col Powell, but in their infancy, they could not supply water to the
four thousand strong population that had moved in over the past two years.
Most of the city was still served by streams, wells, and ponds, breeding
grounds for the plague that was about to strike. Other large cities such
as New York had realized the danger of a contaminated water supply and
after 1866 made great strides to provide clean water. The founders of Birmingham
may have considered their town too small for cholera to gain a foothold
in but they did not take into account that the same social conditions that
existed in large cities now existed in Birmingham due to the close proximity
of the population and the sanitary conditions of some of the communities.
At this point there are conflicts between two
of the sources. One, a physician's report to congress indicates that no
cases were reported for several days after the death of Virgil. Another
written by the wife of one of the physicians, who treated cases in Birmingham
states that another case happened the next day. The report to congress
seems more reliable at this point and picks up with the disease on June
17 when two young girls of the Hughes family took sick. They both died
within a day's time and no effort was made to disinfect their fluids that
were thrown in the creek running through Baconsides. The girls as well
as other members of their family had been attending to Virgil during his
illness and it is probable that at least one of them was infected by contact
with contaminated materials rather than by the drinking water. Unfortunately
by now the creek had been twice exposed and would begin to present problems
very shortly.
At this point another disease vector entered
the city. A shoemaker named Bennet who had been up in Chattanooga Tennessee
returned with a case of diarrhea and died about a day and a half later.
This is the first case in which suitable sanitary precautions were taken
but it was to no avail for a friend of his had handled contaminated materials
and died after being sick for twelve hours. Bennett's sister-in-law who
had stayed by his bedside died as well and since most of the people dying
were those attending the sick, no one took care to sanitize her excrement.
A day later an African American boy in the advanced stages of the disease
was found along the same rail line that had brought in Bennet. He died
very rapidly, within just a few hours of the time that they found him.
The first eight people to come down with the cholera
had all died, all within a day's time, a hundred percent mortality rate.
Though most had received treatment in some form or fashion, they were mostly
poor and the physicians weren't exactly sure how to go about curing them.
Now on June 22 they at least knew what precautions to take against the
further spread of the disease. The board of health issued orders that all
excreta as well as the bed clothes and sheets of the victims were to be
disinfected or burned. The first survivor of the epidemic contracted the
disease on this day. An African American named Eubanks who worked for a
gentleman of the town came down with it at his employer's home. He was
treated and well isolated and no one else in that neighborhood contracted
it. This was also the first appearance of the disease in the more upper
class part of the city and one can see how treatment differed along class
lines within the city.
The most effective response to the cholera in
Birmingham was that of early treatment. Doctors proscribed opium and mercurial
along with an emetic (an agent that causes vomiting). The opium probably
did some good to the victims but the mercury compound and the emetic must
have done more harm than anything else. The physicians limited the amount
of water that they would allow the patient to consume since "unrestrained"
amounts of liquid often resulted in death. Very close care and the opium
seem to be the main reason that many survived, however the disease did
lose some of its virulence with the passing of time. The citizens of Birmingham
also used burning tar and lime to combat the epidemic hoping to sterilize
the air, water, and soil. Montgomery papers ran ads for lime by the barrel
or by the lot. However even the supposed cleansing thunder storm made the
cholera even worse, and the amount of cases reported went up every time
it rained, washing more of the poison in to the streams and ponds.
At the same time that Eubanks's was receiving
his successful treatment in the white community, his fellows in Baconsides
finally ran out of luck with the cleanliness of their drinking water, and
death's were reported in every household in the community. At the beginning
almost all of the victims contracting the disease were black or of the
lower class of the city. The first mention of the epidemic in the Montgomery
press was on July fourth, almost as an afterthought, saying that the disease
was mainly contained within the lower classes. Cholera was often thought
of as being a moral problem and the disease of people of low character.
During the epidemics in the early part of the century, preachers often
gave sermons on how drinking and whoring led to this punishment by God.
If goodly people were infected, it was only because of their proximity
to those of ill repute. This thinking had changed in many parts of the
country but it still held some conviction in the south at this time. In
Birmingham, a blow to this theory was about to be felt, and no longer would
the disease be limited to the lower classes.
It is interesting to note here how the disease
was so often transmitted by the black population. Beginning with Virgil,
carrying through the Baconsides community, and moving into the white parts
of town through hired help such as Eubanks and another man named Leo Anderson.
The disease was even carried down to Montgomery by an African American
who had come to Birmingham to help tend to the sick. The poor conditions
that they lived in, their poor diets and resulting lowered immunity and
the fact that they did not receive the best care possible all contributed
to this problem. It wasn't until the leaders of the town saw that they
too were suffering from the disease that proper treatment was given to
them. Almost all of this population consisted of freed slaves and their
children and had no education to help them realize that they were killing
themselves when they contaminated their drinking water and no money to
leave town when the epidemic found its way into their community.
Ironically, on the same day as the first
reports were appearing in Montgomery, a group of some two hundred citizens
embarked on a journey to Blount Springs to celebrate Independence Day.
Some of the group were apparently infected and "before daylight the
next day seven of their number had died". The disease had now reached
epidemic proportions and individual cases could no longer be reported.
A great exodus began, and almost half of the town departed , running from
an enemy that they could not fight."Every one who could possibly leave
the little stricken city lost no time in getting away. Those who were too
poor and had not the means to go, those whose duty forbade them from leaving
and a few brave and noble ones who were not afraid to face danger, were
all of the well ones left behind." Doctors and ministers worked for
days and weeks straight, tending to the sick. Many of them were stricken
with the disease and a few even read their own obituaries and had coffins
made for them.
On July ninth the disease was raging and finally
given its proper respect in the Montgomery papers. They also give witness
to the great departure and of the current condition of the city, "Families
have been leaving all day every day by every available means. Stores are
closing up generally, even the drinking saloons are shutting their doors."
By July eleventh the citizens of Birmingham appealed to their sister city
to the south for aid. Montgomery sent both money and medical attention
to the disease ridden city.
There are many stories of courage and dedication
during this sad period in Birmingham's early history. A famous madam of
the time named Lou Wooster opened up her brothel to the sick that had no
one else to care for them. She writes, "I was determined to stay and
help nurse the poor sick and suffering ones who needed me." Her acts
of devotion to the city are mentioned in every account of the epidemic,
even in the report to congress. When Wooster died, the gentlemen of the
city sent their carriages to her funeral, socially unable to appear but
wanting to show their respect nevertheless.
Another example was that of Colonel Terry who
had the only house in the city with a rain cistern. He rightly believed
that his water was safer than the communal streams and wells and offered
it to his neighbors so that they could drink. This went on for several
days until his black carriage driver named Leo Anderson contracted the
illness after visiting the Baconsides community. Colonel Terry along with
his wife and other family members got ill but most of them recovered with
the exception of his wife who refused the regular treatment for fear of
harming her nursing baby.
All of the doctors involved made great sacrifices
and the final victim was Dr. Luckie who had worked hard since the beginning
to fight the disease. He grew very ill but recovered, having to learn to
walk again. A druggist named Mr. Smith worked so hard that he had to leave
his post to go home and rest. He apparently came back to work too quickly,
contacted the disease and died despite the best efforts to save him.
The disease finally ran its course through the
end of July and no new cases were reported. The final toll was one hundred
and twenty eight victims with the population halved from its previous four
thousand. A weaker version of the epidemic preyed upon Montgomery for some
time but its southward advance was halted there and luckily didn't travel
down to Mobile or New Orleans. With the coming of autumn and the first
freeze, the last vestiges of the disease were killed off while Birmingham
suffered through the aftermath of the epidemic. "Bats and owls were
the sole occupants of many buildings that had been rented by anxious tenants
only a year and a half before." Outside investors sold out thinking
that the town was done for. Its founders and remaining citizens kept the
faith though, within ten years a water works system provided clean water
for the whole town, and Birmingham continued its dramatic rise as the Magic
City.